The Importance of Providing a Direct and Satisfactory Answer

Introduction

In many situations, people seek answers to their questions in order to obtain useful information or guidance. However, there are instances where individuals provide witty but unhelpful responses that do not address the actual question. This can lead to dissatisfaction and frustration, as the initial inquiry remains unanswered.

Lack of Satisfaction

When someone asks for a recommendation or seeks advice, they are looking for a specific response that addresses their needs. However, when a witty but unhelpful response is given, it fails to provide any useful information or guidance. For example, if someone asks for a recommendation for a good restaurant and the response is to keep going and eventually find them all, it may be clever, but it does not fulfill the purpose of the initial question.

False Assurances

Even if the person providing the unhelpful response assures you that their method will always lead to the desired outcome, it does not change the fact that the initial question was not answered. In the restaurant recommendation example, if the person argues that their method will eventually lead to all the good restaurants in a specific location, it still does not provide a satisfactory answer to the original inquiry.

Petitioners' Argument

In the context of a legal case involving Amgen, a petitioners' argument was presented. Amgen provided evidence that following a certain roadmap always produces the desired antibodies and could potentially produce all the antibodies within the claims. However, this argument is similar to the unhelpful response to the restaurant query, as it does not directly address the specific question or provide a satisfactory answer.

Conclusion

In conclusion, it is important to provide a direct and satisfactory answer to a question, rather than relying on witty but unhelpful responses. These responses may be clever, but they fail to fulfill the purpose of the initial inquiry and can lead to dissatisfaction and frustration. By addressing the actual question and providing useful information or guidance, individuals can ensure that their responses are helpful and meet the needs of those seeking answers.

Publication source

See the PDF from which this article has been generated:

PDF source url: https://www.supremecourt.gov/DocketPDF/21/21-757/254506/20230210111204129_21-757%20bsac%20Intellectual%20Property%20Law%20Professors.pdf