Divine Justice: A Discussion on the Nature of Justice

Introduction

In this dialogue, the characters Mantegna and Momus engage in a conversation about the nature of divine justice. Mantegna explains that divine justice is the ultimate source and standard of all human justice. It is through divine justice that we are able to discern right from wrong and are held accountable for our actions. However, Momus raises the question of how to reconcile the injustices we see in the world with the idea of divine justice.

The Nature of Divine Justice

Mantegna argues that divine justice operates according to its own immutable laws, just as fire burns and water quenches. It is not arbitrary but based on the inherent nature of things. He explains that while there may be instances of injustice in the world, it is not a failure of divine justice but a consequence of human free will. God has given us the ability to choose between good and evil, and with that choice comes the possibility of injustice.

The Role of Human Perspective

Momus questions the infallibility of divine justice, pointing out that there are times when the wicked prosper and the righteous suffer. Mantegna acknowledges this reality but argues that divine justice operates on a different timescale, beyond human understanding. He emphasizes that divine justice is perfect and unerring, even if our limited perspective may lead us to question it.

Faith in Divine Justice

Mantegna concludes by stating that it is not for us to judge the workings of divine justice but rather to strive to live in accordance with its principles. He encourages us to have faith that in the grand scheme of things, divine justice will prevail. While we may not always understand or see the immediate rectification of injustices, we must trust that they will be made right in the end.

Conclusion

This dialogue provides a thought-provoking exploration of the nature of divine justice. Mantegna's arguments highlight the belief that divine justice is the ultimate source and standard of all human justice. While the existence of injustices in the world may challenge our understanding, Mantegna emphasizes the importance of having faith in the infallibility of divine justice.

Publication source

See the PDF from which this article has been generated:

PDF source url: https://openyls.law.yale.edu/bitstream/handle/20.500.13051/5331/Images_of_Justice.pdf